Movie Lovers Reviews: Twilight (2008) - A Lonely Girl Finds Love in all the Wrong Places

Thursday, November 29, 2012

Twilight (2008) - A Lonely Girl Finds Love in all the Wrong Places

Original film poster for Twilight 2008
"Twilight" (2008).

"Twilight" (2008), directed by Catherine Hardwicke for Summit Entertainment based on a script, is based on the best-selling book series. It is difficult to exaggerate the popularity of the "Twilight" series : when each new novel came out, stores around the world set up special tables to sell eager fans copies. It was a marketing phenomenon along the lines of "Harry Potter," and that has carried over to this "Twilight" film, which was a smash success. The "Twilight" film series also is unique in an unusual way which I will get to below, but first let's take a look at this film.

Robter Pattinson as Edward Cullen looking at Kristen Stewart as Bella Swan in Twilight 2008
Bella and Edward. Note that, early in the "Twilight" series, Edward (and Bella) still have reasonably normal skin tones. This shows we have not yet left reality.

Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) is a high school girl who lives with her father (Billie Burke) in the tiny town of Forks, Washington. She never fit in with her classmates at her old high school in Phoenix, but makes friends at her new school. She is attracted to one in particular: handsome Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson).

Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen in Twilight 2008
Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson) is a unique figure who draws Bella's attention.

Cullen doesn't seem to like Bella very much, which confuses Bella. However, one day Bella is walking in the parking lot and gets in the way of a van. Edward steps forward and somehow stops the vehicle with his hand, saving Bella. Afterwards, he remains aloof and tells he that he does not want to be friends.

Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen running through the forest in Twilight 2008

This intrigues Bella, and she starts investigating Edward. She learns that he is a vampire, though he does not attack people, only animals. Eventually, the two start an affair, and Edward introduces Bella to his family, who are all vampires as well.

Kristen Stewart smiling in Twilight 2008

Three wandering vampires - James, Victor and Laurent - visit the Cullens and meet Bella. James (Cam Gigandet) decides he wants to feast on Bella and starts tracking her. She hides in Phoenix, but James sets a trap for her. Lured out into the open, Bella is attacked. James bites her wrist, and the Cullens arrive only just in time to prevent him from killing her. Edward sucks the blood, which contains vampire venom, from Bella's wrist, but Bella secretly wants to become a vampire herself. She still, though, has a lot to learn about her new love.

Bella and Edward Cullen share a tender moment in Twilight 2008

The film tries to stay true to the book, but a lot is left out. Stephanie Meyer was closely involved in production, and fought to preserve the integrity of the project.  The book is almost 500 pages, so not all of it could be included, but Meyer reportedly was pleased with the outcome.

Bella Swan played by Kristen Stewart deep in thought in Twilight 2008

"Twilight" should please fans of the novels. It also should please fans of teen romances in general, vampires or no vampires. Vampires are in, and this series exploits that to the maximum, but the vampirism really is just the obstacle between these two attractive kids falling in love. It is easy to dismiss the film as merely a romance novel turned into film - which, basically, it is - but at least "Twilight" is true to what it tries to be, a tale of a young girl's journey into strange love. If box office figures are any guide, many, many women can relate to Bella and her attraction to the strange and intimidating Edward.

A confrontation between Edward and James in Twilight 2008

Some complain that the chemistry between Bella and Edward is somewhat lacking, but that is part of the tease.  If Edward just jumped at Bella, there wouldn't be much drama!  Another criticism is that Bella is portrayed as too serious by Stewart and is funnier in the book, but that is understandable given how dangerous her situation becomes.  As the series progresses in the sequels, Stewart lightens up a bit, at least by the concluding chapter.

Kristen Stewart as Bella Swan and Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen in the trees in Twilight 2008

The real issue with this film is inherent in its source. This is "dangerous romance" muted and de-fanged so that it is family-friendly. Vampires are portrayed as kindly beings who will satisfy all of our natural urges without doing anything to invade our privacy - except for the bad ones, who have to be beaten off with a stick. It's a slick product perfect for girls afraid of sex, or who wish love was exciting and noble, or who want some kind of "pure" love that doesn't require sex until, you know, the time is right and all that. Edward is so wonderful that Bella can't resist, and all she has to do is take it, without any coercion or prodding from him in the slightest - which is what everyone wants to find in life, isn't it? A passive love interest who is just there, providing excitement and drama and feeding our mating urges and especially our own narcissism. Or at least a very, very large section of the population wants that. Evidently.

Twilight 2008
Bella with an ear bud - real life, real emotions in "Twilight."

I mentioned at the top that the "Twilight" series is unique in an unusual way. Obviously, this is only my opinion, but the unique aspect of the "Twilight" saga is that, creatively at least, it gets worse with each film until it completely loses touch with where it began. This film, the first in the series, has a freshness and air of reality that is squeezed out of each succeeding film like air out of a slowly deflating balloon. We begin the series here with a firm grasp of reality, a lonely and reasonably authentic girl lonely for love like so many others, that is slowly eroded during the course of the film, but still retains some semblance to the real world when these "Twilight" end credits run. As the series proceeds, the real world recedes at an accelerating rate. Eventually, school and ordinary things like that become nothing but a backdrop, a sort of backing scrim for the increasingly baroque vampire plots. One could argue convincingly that, say, the James Bond film series holds steady in its relation to the real world over its run - maybe not very realistic in certain ways from the very beginning, but at least it does not grow completely separated from life as we know it. In the course of the "Twilight" series, though, the real world eventually all but disappears and - I'm not giving anything away here - you really do enter a sort of twilight world, a sort of alternate universe. Here, we start off firmly in reality for the first and last time. For that reason, this original "Twilight" is the film in the series that, to use a trite but apt phrase, best examines the human condition despite the corny vampire plot. For that reason, this "Twilight" is the most interesting film in the series despite also being the most prosaic.

A confrontation between Edward and James in Twilight 2008
This beginning of the "Twilight" series actually contains intriguing interactions that might take place in the real world despite the growing air of unreality.

Yes, there are four sequels to this film (only two were originally planned, and I bet Summit Entertainment wishes they had expanded it even further), each more successful than the last. The Twilight saga finally concludes in 2012's The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 2. The popular book series that fascinated the world also started a firestorm in the film world, and that storm burst out with this film. If you want to understand the "Twilight" phenomenon, you can either read the books, or start watching here. This is a good place to start.


No comments:

Post a Comment